*****Y**** ********** Y***Y***** *****Y**** ******Y***
********** *****Y**** ********** ********** **********
*****Y**** ********** ********** ****Y***** ********Y*
********** ********** ********** ********** **********
****Y***** *****Y**** ********** ********** **Y*******
**
The above shows a graphical portrayal of the 252 Yamal tree ring core data sets available to CRU. The Y indicate the 12 selected by CRU scientists to "prove" global warming.
The other 240 core samples, which did NOT support a global warming theory, were discarded.
They selected only bristlecone and foxtail pine tree ring data sets, ignoring everything else.
No wonder statisticians across the world are up in arms:
A team of statisticians led by Edward Wegman, chair of the National Academy of Sciences' (NAS) Committee on Applied and Theoretical Statistics, was assembled at the request of US Senators.
The team primarily focused on the statistical analysis used in the MBH paper, and also considered the personal and professional relationships between Mann et al. and other members of the paleoclimate community. Findings presented in this report (commonly known as the "Wegman Report") included the following:
- The CRU MBH98 and MBH99 reports were found to be "somewhat obscure and incomplete"
- Criticisms by McIntyre and McKitrick were found to be "valid and compelling."
- It is noted that there is no evidence that Mann or any of the other authors in paleoclimatology studies have had significant interactions with mainstream statisticians.
- Overall, the committee believes that Mann's assessments, that the decade of the 1990s was the hottest decade of the millennium and that 1998 was the hottest year of the millennium, cannot be supported by his analysis
- Many of the same proxies are reused in most of the "independent studies" so these "cannot really claim to be independent verifications."
HOLY SHIT. You don't need a team of statisticians to know that if you select 12 out of 252 samples of data you are fudging results…..
THERE IS NO MAN MADE GOBAL WARMING